The Aeropress vs Pour Over Coffee Maker Debate

Aeropress vs Pour Over Coffee Maker - Which Should You Buy?
Coffee Lovers Guide

If you fancy yourself as an avid coffee lover, choosing the right brewing method and machine is essential. The way in which you choose to make your java will have an extreme effect on the aromas and levels of enjoyment. For this reason, there is a hot debate between Aeropress vs pour over coffee maker and which is the best option.

In this article, we will cover everything you need to know in order to make an informed purchasing decision to help you make your best cup of coffee yet. By the end of it, you will know the answers to the following questions:

  • What an Aeropress coffee maker is
  • What pour over coffee is
  • Prices, pros, and cons of each of the machines
  • Which machine is best used where

Aeropress vs Pour Over Coffee Maker: Which Should You Buy?

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

While some may be happy sipping instant coffee, a true lover of the hot beverage will value the importance of choosing sides in the Aeropress vs pour over coffee maker debate. It’s true that both offer up a mean cup of joe, but it’s undeniable that they offer vastly different flavors and enjoyment qualities.

So, what’s the big deal between these two different machines, you may ask? An Aeropress works solely by using pressure to create a vacuum-sealed chamber that promotes a perfectly extracted flavor from the coffee bean grinds and hot water. This method enhances flavors like nuts and dark fruits due to the manual brewing.

Pour over, on the other hand, makes use of coffee filters, grounds, and hot water. It can also be more of an art to perfect with limited body tastes too. Users can expect more fruity and floral notes with the use of this brewing method.

These two very distinctive ways of brewing coffee come with their own sets of pros and cons. It does, nevertheless, rely heavily on the type of machine used and what your coffee preferences are.

To help you learn more about these brewing methods, we’ll unpack everything you need to know including the best machines to use.

About The Aeropress Coffee and Espresso Maker


AEROPRESS Coffee and Espresso Maker - Quickly Makes Delicious Coffee Without Bitterness - 1 to 3 Cups Per Pressing

Dating back to 2005, the AeroPress company gained major popularity for this particular model.

One of the best advantages that come from using this machine is that it’s extremely versatile in making both a traditional brew and a French press too. You can even mix up your type of java with the different forms of milk and create a brew resembling cappuccinos, lattes, or even iced drinks which is a win in the Aeropress vs pour over battle. This is probably the biggest difference between Aeropress vs pour over.

The AEROPRESS Coffee and Espresso Maker is a great option for those who value a good cup of coffee that comes from a quick and easy setup. It gets bonus points for being a breeze to clean up too! Although it may not be best for groups, it does offer the most convenient way to brew up a quality hot beverage without popping down to visit your local barista.

This press uses a rapid and total immersion brewing system that helps create smooth and flavorful drinks that are free from any bitterness and allows for a low acidity level. Using the patented Aeropress machine, you can expect to make up to 3 cups of java per minute. Due to the ease of use and compact size, it makes for a perfect addition to your home’s kitchen or even for traveling.

How To Use This Machine

Now that you know a bit more about what the Aeropress does, let’s unpack how you can use this machine to achieve that much-desired perfect taste.

What You Will Need:

  • Paper filters
  • Coffee beans of your choice (ground)
  • Grinder
  • Kettle (electric or stovetop based on your preferences)
  • Your favorite mug or tumbler

Step One: Heat Up the Water

It works best when the water reaches 185 degrees F.  Keep in mind that you will only need to boil enough water for your drinking needs.

Step Two: Set Up the Aeropress

The first step in setting up your machine is placing the filter in the drain cape and rinsing it with hot water. Once done, place the cap on. From there, get your go-to mug ready and place the chamber with the now attached cap on the mug. Note that the cap has to be placed filter side down.

Step Three: Start the Brewing Process

Take your grounds and add them to the chamber. When your water reaches the ideal temperature, add that to the chamber too.

As the flavor starts to extract from the grinds, you may note that some residue and CO2 bubbles may rise to the top of your chamber. Should this happen, grab your stirrer and give it a few mixes to ensure that everything is well mixed.

Next, allow between 30-60 seconds for your brew to steep. This will be best in order to extract all those lovely flavors.

Step Four: Carefully Plunge

Last but not least, place the tip of the plunger into the chamber. Then, begin to slowly plunge – the weight of your hand should be the perfect force. The key here is to take your time and to let the plunger fully depress. Once done, remove the press from the cup and enjoy.

Main Features

  • Includes the Aeropress press
  • Uses microfilters for even the more refined grinds
  • Brew chamber
  • Metal filter

What We Like

  • BPA and phthalate-free
  • Compact and easily portable
  • Fast brewing time with rich and smooth tastes
  • Extremely affordable
  • Easy to use and clean

Minor Drawbacks

  • Makes 1-3 servings at a time

You can learn more about the Aeropress coffee maker instructions.

About a Pour Over Coffee Maker

When it comes to the Aeropress vs pour over coffee maker, it should be noted that the latter requires a bit more practice. However, once perfected, you may never go back! The pour over method utilizes similar principles to that of an automatic drip machine. What makes it tricky is the fact that you have to do all the work by hand.

For those extreme java-lovers, take comfort in knowing that this form of brewing was refined after years of experimentation. By using different methods and boiling points, it was discovered that the perfect cup may be achieved through the use of pouring boiling water over coffee that is placed on a filter. This was to alleviate the huffs and puffs that came from the watered-down taste from percolator made drinks.

Since then, there have been a few technological advances to ensure a seamless coffee maker experience. Nowadays, java-makers can expect their cup of Joe to brewed in under 3 minutes. However, you may require a few practices to get your brewing method down to an impressive 3-minute process. It is, however, the chosen practice for barista aficionados!

When debating the use of Aeropress vs pour over methods, it does boil down to your choice of machine.

Mr. Coffee BVMC-PO19B All-in-One Pour Over Coffee Maker, 6 Cups, Black


Mr. Coffee BVMC-PO19B All-in-One Pour Over Coffee Maker, 6 Cups, Black

The Mr. Coffee BVMC-PO19B All-in-One Pour Over Coffee Maker comes highly recommended for those who are willing to test their brewing skills at home. This stainless steel appliance offers an easy to follow step-by-step guide that will walk you through the, otherwise difficult, pour over process.

Making up to 6 cups, this appliance allows users to get the right amount of coffee and boiling temperature for a fantastic tasting hot beverage! This makes it suitable for both home and office use.

How To Use This Machine

Despite the former being easier to prepare in the Aeropress vs pour over debate, luckily pour over doesn’t have to be too tricky to work out, especially with the use of the Mr. Coffee BVMC-PO19B All-in-One Pour Over Coffee Maker.

What You Will Need:

  • Pointed cone filters
  • Coffee beans
  • Grinder
  • Cups or mugs

Step One: Begin to Heat Your Water

First, add your water to the featured gooseneck kettle and place it on the heating plate. When you’re ready to start brewing, select the on/off button for the kettle. Next, it’s important to switch on the scale to activate the auto-measure features which will come in handy when you’re ready to add your grounds.

Step Two: Install the Carafe

The next step is to set up the carafe followed by the necessary paper cone filter.

Step Three: Add Your Grounds

After switching on the auto-measure feature, press the “next” button which will tell you when to add the coffee. From there, make use of the serving size button to establish how much coffee will be needed. You can use regular, decaf or any of the many types of coffee available today.

Step Four: Start Pouring

With the grounds ready to go and your kettle being optimally boiled, it’s time to get pouring! The progress bar will tell you when to stop pouring and when you should allow for the blooming process to begin.

Main Features

  • Auto measure scale to automatically calculate the coffee to water ratio
  • Temperature controlled gooseneck kettle
  • Cone style brewer
  • On-screen guide that indicates when to pause for blooming

What We Like

  • The on-screen guide is extremely helpful for pour over newbies
  • Better equipped to handle bigger drink orders
  • Optional cup measurements

Minor Drawbacks

  • No warming plate
  • Carafe isn’t insulated
  • Cone filters aren’t included
  • Isn’t suited for traveling

Final Thoughts

So, who wins in the Aeropress vs pour over coffee maker argument? It all depends on your drinking preferences and how much you’re willing to go through to achieve the perfect cup.

The AEROPRESS Coffee and Espresso Maker is a fantastic option for those who like robust and smooth flavors that come simply. On the other hand, the Mr. Coffee Pour Over Coffee Maker is great for newbies who are trying to perfect the renowned pour over process. Depending on your personal preferences, both machines can brew up an amazing cup of Joe!

You might also like:

Pour Over Coffee Vs French Press Coffee Brewer information

Understanding the Difference Between Pour Over and Drip Coffee

(Visited 716 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply